Texas Supreme Court November 24, 2015, 14-14-00077-CV (MKM Engineers, Inc., and Pika International, Inc. v. Jal B. Guzder)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-11-2015

Reversed and Remanded and Opinion filed November 24, 2015.

In The

Fourteenth Court of Appeals

NO. 14-14-00077-CV

MKM ENGINEERS, INC., AND PIKA INTERNATIONAL, INC., Appellants

V.

JAL B. GUZDER, Appellee

On Appeal from the 434th Judicial District Court

Fort Bend County, Texas

Trial Court Cause No. 07-DCV-155803A

OPINION

Appellee Jal B. Guzder sued appellants MKM Engineers, Inc. (“MKM”) and

PIKA International, Inc. (“PIKA”), seeking to enforce a Rule 11 agreement to

settle pending litigation. Guzder moved for summary judgment on his breach of

contract claim, and MKM and PIKA jointly filed a cross-motion for summary

judgment contending that the Rule 11 agreement was unenforceable. The trial

court granted a judgment in favor of Guzder. In six issues, MKM and PIKA

contend that the trial court erred by granting Guzder’s motion for summary

judgment and denying MKM and PIKA’s cross-motion. We conclude that the

agreement is enforceable, but fact issues concerning Guzder’s performance under

the Rule 11 agreement preclude summary judgment in his favor. We reverse and

remand.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

MKM provides environmental remediation and disposal of unexploded

munitions to government agencies. Its customers include the United States Army

Corps of Engineers, the Department of Homeland Security, Defense Reutilization

Marketing Services, and the Environmental Protection Agency. Khodi Irani is

MKM’s majority shareholder. MKM was a participant in the Small Business

Administration’s “Minority Set-aside Program,” also referred to as the “8(a)

program,” which is designed to help small businesses obtain government contracts.

Similar to MKM, PIKA is an environmental consultant and remediation firm

whose primary customers are U.S. government agencies. PIKA also participated in

the 8(a) program. Tirandaz Kasnavia is PIKA’s owner and Irani’s brother-in-law.

Guzder owns an environmental remediation consulting company named

Energy & Environmental Technology Company (“EETCO”).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.