Vermont Superior Court May 15, 2015, 107 (Fifield v. Autobahn Body Works, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2015

Fifield v. Autobahn Body Works, Inc., No. 107-2-15 Cncv (Toor, J., May 15, 2015).

[The text of this Vermont trial court opinion is unofficial. It has been reformatted from the original. The accuracy

of the text and the accompanying data included in the Vermont trial court opinion database is not guaranteed.]

VERMONT SUPERIOR COURT

CHITTENDEN UNIT

CIVIL DIVISION

│

CURTIS FIFIELD │

Plaintiff │

│

v. │ Docket No. 107-2-15 Cncv

│

│

AUTOBAHN BODY WORKS, INC., et al., │

Defendants │

│

RULING ON MOTION FOR WRIT OF ATTACHMENT

Plaintiff alleges that, when he was incarcerated a number of months ago, he left a large

and valuable box of his mechanic’s tools at the shop where he was working. He sues the shop

and its owners for negligence for allowing the toolbox to disappear while he was incarcerated.

He seeks a writ of attachment for the value of the toolbox and its contents. A hearing was held on

the motion on March 18 and April 21. Post-hearing memos were complete May 8. Harley

Brown, Esq. represents Plaintiff; Richard Goldsborough, Esq. represents Defendants.

Findings of Fact

For purposes of the motion for attachment, the court finds the following facts to be

established by a preponderance of the evidence. Autobahn is owned by Patrick and Terese Ayer.

The real estate on which the shop sits is owned by them personally, not by Autobahn. Fifield

worked as a mechanic at Autobahn on and off over the years. He was not an employee, but an

independent contractor or subcontractor. He had his own large toolbox which he brought to

Autobahn, which apparently is common practice among mechanics. It was about five feet long,

two feet deep, and over three feet high. It was heavy, although it had wheels. Fifield estimates

that the box was worth $5,000 empty and had about $18,000 worth of tools inside, for a total

value of $23,000.

In January of 2014, Fifield was arrested and taken to jail. He remained incarcerated until

September 29, 2014.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.