Vermont Superior Court March 20, 2015, 123-9-13 Vtec (Moore 3-Lot SD)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-03-2015

STATE OF VERMONT

SUPERIOR COURT ENVIRONMENTAL DIVISION

Vermont Unit Docket No. 123-9-13 Vtec

Moore 3 Lot Subdivision DECISION ON THE MERITS

James and Mia Moore (the Moores) seek to subdivide the 6.27-acre parcel they own at

18 Leap Frog Hollow Road in the City of Montpelier, Vermont. The Moores’ subdivision

application was approved by the Montpelier Development Review Board (the DRB) by written

decision dated August 19, 2013. Neighboring property owner James Nagle (Mr. Nagle) timely

appealed that decision to this Court and raised 15 questions for the Court’s review.

In a July 28, 2014 decision we addressed the Moores’ motion to dismiss and the parties’

cross-motions for summary judgment. We GRANTED judgment to the Moores on Questions 1–

11 and 13–15 of Mr. Nagle’s Statement of Questions. As to Question 12, we concluded there

was a material dispute of facts regarding whether the Moores’ application meets the

requirements of the Montpelier Zoning and Subdivision Regulations related to the delineation

of environmental resources, and thus we denied summary judgment on Question 12. Finally,

we denied Mr. Nagle’s request that the application be remanded to the DRB. Thus, Question

12 remained for trial.

The Court completed a site visit to the Property on the morning of December 16, 2014

immediately followed by a merits hearing at the Washington County, Civil Division in

Montpelier, Vermont. Appearing at the site visit and merits hearing were James Moore and his

attorney Daniel Burke, Esq., and James Nagle, participating as a self-represented litigant.

Based upon the evidence presented at trial, including that which was put into context by

the site visit, the Court renders the following Findings of Fact.

Factual Background

1. James and Mia Moore purchased a 6.27-acre parcel of land on Leap Frog Hollow Road in

the City of Montpelier in May 2012.

1

2. The 6.27-acre parcel was once part of a larger parcel owned by Mr. Nagle. Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.