Vermont Superior Court February 13, 2015, 71-5-14 Vtec (Orlandi Act 250 Kennel Permit)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-02-2015

STATE OF VERMONT

SUPERIOR COURT ENVIRONMENTAL DIVISION

Vermont Unit Docket No. 71-5-14 Vtec

Orlandi Act 250 Kennel Permit

(Application No. 9A0349) DECISION ON MOTION

Claudia Orlandi ("Ms. Orlandi”) seeks an Act 250 Land Use Permit for an existing dog

breeding kennel located on Monkton Road in the Town of Monkton, Vermont (“the Town”).

The District # 9 Environmental Commission (“the Commission”) approved Ms. Orlandi’s

application and issued Permit # 9A0349 (“the Permit”), along with Findings of Fact, Conclusions

of Law, and Order dated April 24, 2014. Abutting property owners Allan and Michael Brisson

timely appealed that decision to this Court. Ms. Orlandi has now moved to dismiss the appeal

for Appellants’ lack of standing and for judgment on the pleadings. Ms. Orlandi is represented

by attorney James A. Dumont, and Appellants are represented by attorneys Matthew E.

Rohrbaugh, Colin R. Hagan, and David J. Shlansky. Also participating in this appeal is the

Vermont Natural Resources Board (“NRB”) represented by attorney Peter J. Gill.

Factual Background

For the sole purpose of putting the pending motions into context the Court recites the

following facts which it understands to be undisputed unless otherwise noted:

1. Ms. Orlandi owns approximately 194-acres of land (“the Property)” located on the west

side of Monkton Road in the Town of Monkton, Vermont.

2. Ms. Orlandi, a world famous breeder and exhibiter of basset hounds, owns and operates

a dog breeding kennel on the Property where she breeds and trains basset hounds for show. Of

the dogs she breeds, Ms. Orlandi sells only those she decides not to keep for show, amounting

to approximately 10 dogs per year.

3. Ms. Orlandi has operated a dog kennel on the Property without an Act 250 Land Use

Permit since the early 1990s. The kennel is for breeding purposes only; it does not function as a

boarding kennel. The only non-resident dogs permitted on the Property are those to be bred

with one of Ms. Orlandi’s hounds.

4.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.