Nevada Supreme Court March 26, 2015, 61059 (BULLION MONARCH MINING VS. BARRICK GOLDSTRIKE MINES (NRAP 5))

Also known as

United States · · · 26-03-2015

131 Nev., Advance Opinion IS

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA

BULLION MONARCH MINING, INC., No. 61059

Appellant,

vs.

FILED

BARRICK GOLDSTRIKE MINES, INC., MAR 2 6 2015

Respondent. 1E K. L)NDEMAN

RT

BY

CHIEF DE CLERK

Certified questions under NRAP 5 concerning whethei - the

rule against perpetuities applies to an area-of-interest provision in a

commercial mining agreement for the payment of royalties and, if so,

whether reformation of the agreement is available under NRS 111.1039.

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit; Sidney R. Thomas,

Chief Circuit Judge, M. Margaret McKeown and William A. Fletcher,

Circuit Judges.

Question answered.

Lewis Roca Rothgerber LLP and Daniel F. Polsenberg and Joel D.

Henriod, Las Vegas,

for Appellant.

Parsons, Behle & Latimer and Michael R. Kealy, Reno; Parsons, Behle &

Latimer and Francis M. Wikstrom, Salt Lake City, Utah,

for Respondent.

Baker & Hostetler LLP and Mary P. Birk, Denver, Colorado,

for Amicus Curiae Mary Ann Schmidt.

BEFORE THE COURT EN BANC.

SUPREME COURT

OF

NEVADA

(0) 1947A

CDrreefeti pef lzfre,--tv

16 - Cq 13 7

OPINION

By the Court, CHERRY, J.:

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals certified two questions to

this court concerning Nevada's rule against perpetuities. The first

question asks whether Nevada's "Rule Against Perpetuities appl[ies] to an

area-of-interest provision in a commercial mining agreement." The second

asks whether, if the rule applies, courts may reform such agreements

under NRS 111.1039(2). We accepted the certified questions and directed

briefing.

We conclude that Nevada's common-law rule against

perpetuities does not extend to area-of-interest royalties created by

commercial mining agreements. Courts developed the rule to promote

public policy by ensuring that property remained alienable. Applying the

rule to area-of-interest royalty agreements does not further public policy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.