Court of Appeals of Washington February 12, 2015, No. 31854-1-III (Zavala v. Twin City Foods)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-2015

¶1 — The Board of Industrial Insurance Appeals closed Ana Zavala’s industrial insurance claim, which ruling the Franklin County Superior Court affirmed. Zavala appeals and asks this court to reopen her claim or, in the alternative, to increase her disability rating. The appeal requires discussion of the “lit up” doctrine under workers’ compensation law. Zavala primarily argues that her testimony and the testimony of friends and family that she experienced no pain before her work injury requires the trial court to find that she suffered from no preexisting condition, despite medical testimony to the contrary. Because the trial court has the discretion to believe the testimony of physicians over lay witnesses and because we defer to the trial court’s findings, we affirm the superior court.

Fearing, J.

FACTS

¶2 On September 17, 2007, Ana Zavala, then age 52, injured her left knee in the course of employment with Twin City Foods. Zavala testified concerning the circumstances of the injury:

*842I was cleaning an area, and my supervisor said, “This area needs to be clean in 15 minutes, it has to be very clean,” and I was hurrying up. I was putting chlorine and soap and I was washing the area quickly, and I hit my knee, and ever since then I have not been able to walk.

Admin. Record (AR) at 461. Zavala hit her knee against the flat edge of a tub. Zavala finished her work on September 17, but then went to Lourdes Occupational Health Center for an assessment.

¶3 In October 2007, orthopedic surgeon Christopher Kontogianis examined Ana Zavala. An October 3, 2007, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed fluid in her left knee, a tear of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus, and a complete tear of the medial collateral ligament from the tibial insertion. A “meniscus” is a c-shaped cartilage disk found in the knee. The medial meniscus lies on the inner side of the knee, and the lateral meniscus rests on the outer side of the knee.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.