District Court of Appeal of Florida July 24, 2015, No. 5D14-3309 (Romero v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-07-2015

COHEN, J.

Frank Romero appeals his convictions for two counts of lewd or lascivious molestation and one count of lewd or lascivious conduct. We affirm as to all issues raised on appeal, but write to address the trial judge’s handling of the jury’s request for trial transcripts.

After beginning deliberations, the jury asked a series of questions, one of which was whether transcripts of the testimony were available.1 The prosecutor and the court responded that transcripts were not available. Although defense counsel suggested that the testimony could be read back, when the trial judge summarized his proposed answers to the various questions propounded — including informing the jury that transcripts were unavailable — defense counsel assented to those answers.

Romero relies on Hazuri v. State, 91 So.3d 836 (Fla.2012), to argue that his conviction must be reversed. In Hazuri, the Florida Supreme Court explained that a trial judge should not use any language that would mislead a jury into believing that read-backs are prohibited. Id. at 845-46. Simply informing the jury that transcripts are unavailable does just that. When a jury inquires about the availability of trial transcripts, the judge should instruct the jury that transcripts are unavailable but that the jury can request to have any testimony read back. Id. at 846. The judge should also ask the jury to specify which testimony they wish to review. Id. This clarification is required so that the trial judge may appropriately exercise his or her discretion in ruling on any read-back requests. Id.

Romero correctly notes that the trial court neither informed the jury of the possibility of a read-back nor asked the jury to specify which testimony they want*1263ed to review. The technological issues involved when proceedings are recorded, rather than taken down stenographically, are not insurmountable. Digitally recorded- courtrooms are monitored to ensure that a record is produced.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.