Louisiana Court of Appeal January 7, 2015, No. 2014 CA 0420 (Smith v. Allied Waste Ind., Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-01-2015

THERIOT, J.

This appeal is taken from a judgment signed October 10, 2012, in favor of plaintiff, Vivian L. Smith, and against defendant, Clarence T. Nails, Jr.1 Notice of judgment was mailed to both Mr. Nails and his attorney of record, Otha Nelson, on October 12, 2012. Mr. Nails filed a motion for new trial on November 15, 2012. After a hearing, the motion for new trial was denied on August 22, 2013. On September 19, 2013, Mr. Nails filed a motion and order for suspensive appeal from the August 22, 2013 judgment denying his motion for new trial. He filed his surety bond on October 21, 2013.

This court, ex proprio motu, issued a rule on June 5, 2014, ordering the parties to show cause as to whether the appeal should be dismissed as untimely. The rule to show cause states that both the November 15, 2012 motion for new trial and the September 19, 2013 motion and order for appeal appear to be untimely.

Mr. Nails filed an untimely response to the rule to show cause. He claimed that his motion for new trial was timely and therefore suspended the appeal delays. Mr. Nails first argued that he “believes” he actually filed two motions for new trial, the first of which was prepared in July 2012 (after the issuance of the court’s reasons for judgment, but before the judgment was ever signed). However, regardless of when the motion was prepared, the record does not reflect that he ever actual*386ly filed that motion for new trial. Mr. Nails also argues that his November 15, 2012 motion for new trial was timely because the notice of judgment was not actually mailed on October 12, 2012, as the certification contained in the record states, but rather “on or about November 8, 2012.” Again, there is no evidence to support this 13assertion, and appellant is “unable to locate the envelope” that contained the October 10, 2012 judgment.

The statutory delays for motions for new trial or for appeal are governed by La. C.C.P. arts. 1974, 2087, and 2123.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.