Court of Appeals of Utah December 31, 2015, 20140662-CA (Guzman v. Labor Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-2015

2015 UT App 310

THE UTAH COURT OF APPEALS

SOCORRO GUZMAN,

Petitioner,

v.

LABOR COMMISSION, CIRCLE FOUR FARMS, AND INDEMNITY

INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH AMERICA,

Respondents.

Memorandum Decision

No. 20140662-CA

Filed December 31, 2015

Original Proceeding in this Court

Loren M. Lambert, Attorney for Petitioner

Jaceson R. Maughan, Attorney for Respondent

Labor Commission

Eric K. Jenkins and Kristen C. Kiburtz, Attorneys for

Respondents Circle Four Farms and Indemnity

Insurance Company of North America

JUDGE KATE A. TOOMEY authored this Memorandum Decision, in

which JUDGE JAMES Z. DAVIS concurred.1 JUDGE JOHN A. PEARCE

concurred in the result.2

1. Judge James Z. Davis began his work on this case as a member

of the Utah Court of Appeals. He retired from the court on

November 16, 2015, but thereafter became a Senior Judge. He

completed his work on the case, sitting by special assignment as

authorized by law. See generally Utah R. Jud. Admin 11-201(6).

2. Judge John A. Pearce participated in this case as a member of

the Utah Court of Appeals. He became a member of the Utah

Supreme Court on December 17, 2015, before this decision

issued.

Guzman v. Labor Commission

TOOMEY, Judge:

¶1 Socorro Guzman seeks judicial review of the Utah Labor

Commission’s Appeals Board’s (the Board) denial of permanent

total disability benefits. Because the Board erred in determining

that Guzman’s impairments do not limit his ability to do basic

work activities, we set aside its order and remand for further

proceedings consistent with this decision.

BACKGROUND

¶2 In 2008, while working for Circle Four Farms, Guzman

was ‚forcefully butted‛ by a three- to four-hundred-pound boar.

He was thrown and landed on the cement floor of the pen,

injuring his lower back and right hip. Although Guzman

continued to work after the accident, his low-back pain

worsened and he ultimately stopped working in July 2009. He

has not been gainfully employed since.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.