Court of Appeals of Utah September 17, 2015, 20140614-CA (Zisumbo v. Ogden Regional Medical Center)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-09-2015

2015 UT App 240

THE UTAH COURT OF APPEALS

RAYMOND L. ZISUMBO,

Appellant,

v.

OGDEN REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, CHRIS BISSENDEN,

ANTHONY RODEBUSH, AND JUDD TAYLOR,

Appellees.

Opinion

No. 20140614-CA

Filed September 17, 2015

Second District Court, Ogden Department

The Honorable Ernest W. Jones

No. 130900392

April L. Hollingsworth, Attorney for Appellant

Michael Patrick O’Brien, Mark D. Tolman, and Jesse

M. Oakeson, Attorneys for Appellees

JUDGE J. FREDERIC VOROS JR. authored this Opinion, in which

JUDGES MICHELE M. CHRISTIANSEN and KATE A. TOOMEY

concurred.

VOROS, Judge:

¶1 This appeal requires us to determine whether a plaintiff

alleging a variety of tort and contract claims adequately pleaded

causation. We conclude that the amended complaint satisfied

our liberal pleading rules and so reverse the district court’s order

dismissing the amended complaint.

Zisumbo v. Ogden Regional Medical Center

BACKGROUND 1

¶2 Raymond L. Zisumbo worked as a computer tomography

(CT) technician for Ogden Regional Medical Center for five

years. In September 2009, Zisumbo filed discrimination

complaints against his supervisor, Anthony Rodebush, with

Ogden Regional’s parent corporation, Hospital Corporation

America (HCA), and with the Utah Labor Commission. In

October 2009, Ogden Regional terminated Zisumbo’s

employment. 2

¶3 Ogden Regional maintains a database in which it codes

the reason for an employee’s termination. The code assigned to a

terminated employee indicates that employee’s eligibility for

rehire. Other HCA medical facilities, including St. Mark’s

Hospital, also use this database to make hiring decisions.

Sometime after Ogden Regional terminated Zisumbo’s

employment in 2009, Ogden Regional coded Zisumbo as “‘Invol

Term—Miscond’ . . . believing that it made him eligible for

rehire.” In March 2011, Ogden Regional “learned this [belief]

was incorrect” and that the assigned code made Zisumbo

ineligible for rehire at all HCA medical facilities.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.