Supreme Court of Colorado May 11, 2015, Supreme Court Case No. 14SA179 (Concerning Application for Water Rights of East Cherry Creek Valley Water v. Greeley Irrigation Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-05-2015

JUSTICE HOBBS

delivered the Opinion of the Court.

1 1 This appeal concerns a change of water right case filed by applicants East Cherry Creek Valley Water and Sanitation District and Colorado Water Network, Inc. (collectively "East Cherry Creek Valley"). East Cherry Creek Valley submitted an application for a change of water right involving shares it owns in the Greeley Irrigation Company ("GIC") for use in its water system. A prior change case, the Poudre Prairie *437Decree1, employed a ditch-wide analysis for calculating the amount of historical consumptive use ascribable to each GIC share. Subsequent decrees involving a change of water right in connection with GIC shares have relied upon the ditch-wide historical consumptive use determination made in the Poudre Prairie Decree. In this case, East Cherry Creek Valley's application asserts its ability to use the same Poudre Prairie pro-rata allocation of consumptive use water to its shares as occurred for previously changed shares in the ditch system.

1 2 Accordingly, East Cherry Creek Valley filed a motion under C.R.C.P. 56(h) seeking three water court rulings: (1) that the earlier ditch-wide quantification in the Poudre Prairie Decree precluded requantification of East Cherry Creek Valley's water right after entry of that decree in 1998; (2) that East Cherry Creek Valley did not have the burden to establish claim preclusion through a showing of no changed cireumstances; and (8) that the court should not allow evidence at trial regarding changed cireumstances. The water court denied the motion.

T3 East Cherry Creek Valley then sought an order from the water court entering the denial of its Rule 56(h) motion as a final Judgment pursuant to C.R.C.P. 54(b). The State and Division Engineers ("the Engineers") opposed this motion. The water court granted East Cherry Creek Valley's 54(b) motion and certified its Rule 56(h) order as a final judgment. East Cherry Creek Valley presented three issues on appeal. .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.