Kentucky Supreme Court December 17, 2015, 2013-SC-000367-DG (Commonwealth v. Young)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-12-2015
lead-opinion
OPINION OF THE COURT BY
JUSTICE NOBLE
This case presents the question whether biological parents who accept living expenses from two different sets of prospective adoptive parents without disclosing that fact may be charged with and convicted of theft by deception. It also presents the question whether the amounts paid by the two sets of prospective adoptive parents may be combined to elevate the theft, which would otherwise have been a Class D felony, above the $10,000 threshold to make it a Class C felony.
The biological parents in this case, Michael and Janie Young, raised the first issue to the trial court by moving to dismiss the indictment for failure to state a crime. The trial court denied the motion, and the Youngs entered guilty pleas conditioned on their right to appeal that decision. The Youngs never expressly raised the second question to the trial court, though they and the Commonwealth entered into stipulations of fact that touch on it.
The Court of Appeals reversed their convictions, holding that there was no theft by deception and thus no crime had been committed. The court held that the indictment should have been dismissed, and thus declined to address the second question as moot.
We agree with the trial court that the indictment in this case stated a public offense and therefore could not be dismissed. We reach the second question raised and conclude that the amounts may not be combined to elevate the level of the offense, and that this amounted to palpable error. We therefore reverse the Court of Appeals to the extent that it required the indictment to be dismissed, but we affirm to the extent that it vacated the Youngs’ convictions.
I.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit