New York Supreme Court June 25, 2015 (Peters v. Smolian)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-06-2015

OPINION OF THE COURT

Thomas F. Whelan, J.

It is ordered that those portions of this motion (No. 001) by plaintiffs for summary judgment on their first cause of action for declaratory relief is denied with respect to defendant Richard J. Smolian, as he defaulted in answering which precludes an award of summary judgment due to the failure to join issue and it is denied with respect to the other defendants, to whom the court awards reverse summary judgment and hereby declares that the “stranger to the deed” rule is not applicable and thus does not invalidate nor render unenforceable the preemptive right of first refusal in favor of answering defendants, Randy Smolian, Jonathan Smolian and Darielle Smolian, that is contained in certain deeds and that the plaintiffs are not free to convey the subject property without regard to said right of first refusal; and it is further ordered that those portions of this motion wherein the plaintiffs seek summary judgment on their second cause of action for a declaration that the defendants possessed of the right of first refusal must *411match all of the terms of the contract for the sale of the subject property is denied due to the plaintiffs’ failure to establish compliance with the terms, of the right of first refusal and such cause of action is dismissed due to a lack of a justiciable controversy.

This case involves conflicting claims concerning a right of first refusal set forth in various deeds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.