District Court, S.D. Illinois January 12, 2015, Case No. 12-CV-881-NJR-PMF (United States ex rel. Garbe v. Kmart Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-01-2015

AMENDED MEMORANDUM . AND ORDER

ROSENSTENGEL, District Judge:

Pending before the Court are five motions filed by Defendant Kmart Corporation (“Kmart”): a Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on Payers Definitions of Usual and Customary Price (Doc. 204); a Motion to Exclude the Expert Testimony of Dale A. Chamberlain (Doc. 212); a Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on Claims in Other Than 90-Day Quantities (Doc. 203); a Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on Pre-FERA Claims Relating to Medicare Part D (Doc. 205); and a Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on All Claims Submitted to Medicare Part D (Doc. 206). For the reasons set forth below, the Court grants in part and denies in part the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on Payers Definitions of Usual and Customary Price (Doc. 204), denies the Motion to Exclude the Expert Testimony of Dale A. Chamberlain (Doc. 212), denies the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on Claims in Other Than 90-Day Quantities (Doc. 203), denies the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment based on Pre-FERA Claims Relating to Medicare Part D (Doc. 205), and denies the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Based on All Claims Submitted to Medicare Part D (Doc. 206).

Summary of the Relevant Facts & Procedural History1

Relator James Garbe (“Relator”) has brought this action qui tam on behalf of the United States Government.2 Relator was an employee of Kmart and worked in Kmart stores in Ohio and Michigan as a pharmacist from May 2007 through October 2010, when he resigned (Doc. 207, p. 1). Relator is currently retired (Id.).

Kmart Corporation currently operates 780 pharmacies in its stores in forty-six states, Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands (Doc. 207, p. 1). In 2005, Kmart operated 1,120 pharmacies in its stores, and the number has been declining since then (Id.). Kmart’s current national market share for pharmacy is less than one percent of the market (Id.).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.