District Court, N.D. Indiana September 17, 2015, Cause No. 2:14-CV-238-PPS-JEM (Stopinc Aktiengesellschaft v. J.W. Hicks, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-09-2015
OPINION AND ORDER
PHILIP P. SIMON, Chief Judge.
This is a patent infringement case dealing with equipment used in processing molten metal. The invention at issue is a slide gate on a container that holds molten metal. Basically, the slide gate is the part of a large metal container that opens and dispenses the liquid metal inside into, whatever other containers are being used. Plaintiff Stopinc Aktiengesellschaft is a Swiss company that, among other things, manufactures these slide gates. Stopinc patented this invention in 2002 and now claims that Defendant J.W. Hicks, Inc. is infringing by producing essentially the same type ’of slide gate. I say “essentially” because the parties agree that there are differences between the Stopinc arid J.W. Hicks slide gates. The fact that theré are differences between' the products is not, however, in and of itself necessarily problematic because Stopinc’s legal theory is under the doctrine of equivalents. So Stopinc can sue J.W. Hicks .for infringement even if the products are not 100% the same. J.W. Hicks contends that the doctrine of equivalents is unavailable to Stopinc. To this effect, J.W. Hicks has filed a Motion for Summary Judgment (DE 35) claiming that during the prosecution of Stopinc’s patent, it affirmatively represented to the Patent Office that its invention did not include the feature that allegedly makes J.W. Hicks’ slide gate similar to Stopinc’s, so the doctrine of equivalents can’t apply. • That’s the primary motion before me today. Since the doctrine of equivalents is the only theory of infringement that Stopinc.relies upon, this motion is potentially case dispositive.
This matter has been fully briefed, including some supplemental filings received from the parties (DE’s 51-52) and I have also heard oral argument (DE 50). After reviewing all of those materials, and for the reasons discussed below, I agree with *766J.W. Hicks that the doctrine of equivalents isn’t available to Stopinc.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit