District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania October 30, 2015, CIVIL ACTION No. 12-06223 (Charles v. UPS National Long Term Disability Plan)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-10-2015
MEMORANDUM
Stengel, District Judge
This case stems from Aetna’s' denial of long-term disability benefits ünder an ERISA-covered- employee benefits plan.1 The parties have filed cross motions for summary judgment. For the reasons stated below, I will grant the plaintiffs motion in part and enter judgment in favor of the plaintiff on Count I. - ,
1. BACKGROUND
Plaintiff Marvin Charles is a 57-year-old high school graduate.2 He started working *385at UPS as a Pre-loader/Porter.3 He was promoted to the role of package car driver in 1992, making between $50,000-60,000 a year.4 Prior to working at UPS, Mr. Charles was a dock worker for eight years and a self-employed farm owner for twelve years.5 As part of his employment with UPS, Mr. Charles participated in the UPS National Long-term Disability Benefits Plan.6
About thirty years ago, Mr, Charles was in a motor vehicle accident causing him brain trauma.7 Subsequently, he was diagnosed with partial complex seizure disorder.8 The plaintiff took Depakote for several months and then stopped.9 He remained seizure-free for many, many years.10 In .the spring of 2008, he began working with his doctor to again treat the condition after having a grand mal seizure.11-His primary care physician (PCP) referred him for blood tests and an MRI/MRA . of the brain.12 His PCP also told him to see his neurologist , about “initiating medication.”13 His neurologist then prescribed a medication called lamotrigine, also known as Lamictal, to control his seizures.14 Because he was taking anti-seizure medication, the plaintiff could no longer drive a truck for UPS because Department of Transportation regulations prevented him from doing so.15
Mr. Charles stopped working at UPS on June 1, 2009.16 He applied for short-term *386disability (STD) benefits, which he began receiving on June 8, 2009.17 Those benefits, paid through the Central Pennsylvania Teamsters Health and Welfare Fund, expired on February 17, 2010.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit