Court of Appeals of Oregon November 4, 2015, 120934165; A154660 (State v. Nesbit)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-2015

FLYNN, J.

Defendant appeals from a judgment imposing enhanced sentences for two of three counts of aggravated theft in the first degree, ORS 164.057, following his plea of no contest to an indictment charging three counts of aggravated theft in the first degree. The trial court sentenced defendant to probation on Count 1 and then counted the conviction on Count 1 as a previous conviction to support the enhanced sentences on Counts 2 and 3. See ORS 137.717(l)(a)(A) (2009).1 We conclude that the state failed to meet its burden to prove that the three counts of aggravated theft arose out of separate criminal episodes, and, thus, that the state failed to prove that the conviction on Count 1 was a previous conviction for purposes of his sentences on the other counts. Accordingly, we reverse and remand for resentencing.

The state bears the burden of proving by a preponderance of evidence that defendant’s conviction on Count 1 qualifies as a “previous conviction.” See ORS 137.079(5)(c); ORS 137.717(8).2 The parties agree that the conviction on Count 1 could serve as a “previous conviction” for purposes of enhancing defendant’s sentence on the other aggravated theft convictions, unless the later convictions arose out of the “same conduct or criminal episode” as Count 1. See ORS 137.717(4)(a) (2009);3 State v. Mallory, 213 Or App 392, *696395-96, 162 P3d 297 (2007), rev den, 344 Or 110 (2008) (explaining what constitutes a previous conviction). The only issue in dispute is whether the trial court correctly determined that defendant’s “acceptance of checks during a different time period, is a separate criminal act and a separate episode.”

Whether conduct giving rise to convictions constitutes a single criminal episode is a question of law, although the answer to that question “may depend on predicate findings of historical fact.” State v. Potter, 236 Or App 74, 82, 234 P3d 1073 (2010). Here, the historical facts presented by the record are not in dispute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.