Charlottesville County Circuit Court July 27, 2015, Case No. CL14-283 (Lewis v. Just Right Real Estate Dev., Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-07-2015
By Judge Richard E. Moore
I have re-read and reviewed the entire file, including my notes, and all the pleadings, memoranda, and briefs. I am going to deny the Motion To Dismiss for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction. I will grant Plaintiff leave to amend as to damages.
The starting point, in my consideration and analysis, is Judge Hogshire’s ruling on November 13,2014, that Defendants were in default and had been given ample opportunity to file proper and timely responses, and to seek the assistance of counsel if they were so inclined. Apparently they were not, as they neither filed proper pleadings nor hired counsel. They apparently had been admonished by the Court at a previous hearing on October 20 to seek counsel and file any pleadings by November 3. At some point after the November 13 hearing (for which the order granting default judgment as to liability was entered by Judge Hogshire December 16), the Defendants retained counsel; I believe on December 8. Mr. Lewis then filed his Motion for Relief from-the Default Judgment on December 10, 2014.
Defendant’s counsel also filed on January 5, 2015, a Motion To Stay Default Judgment to allow argument on January 7, 2015, twenty-two days after entry of default judgment. The Court did grant the temporary request, and suspended the judgment on January 6 to allow the parties to address the matter January 7.
After reconsideration, the Court reinstated Judge Hogshire’s default judgment as to liability. The matter of damages remained an open issue. Mr. Lewis then filed his Motion To Dismiss.
While jurisdiction may be raised at any time during the proceedings, it is noteworthy that such was not raised at any time by the Defendants, who were representing themselves, when they filed the demurrer and the motion *419in limine. More pertinent, it was not raised by the Defendants’ current counsel when he filed his Motion for Relief and his Motion for a Stay.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit