Richmond County Circuit Court September 24, 2015, Case No. CL14-1692 (Commonwealth v. ProNurses)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-09-2015
By Judge John F. Daffron
The Parties came, by counsel, before this Court on May 26 and 28, 2015, for a bench trial in this matter. After the Parties presented all evidence and arguments, the Court ordered the Parties to submit post-trial briefs. The Court received a brief from the Commonwealth but did not from any Defendant. Accordingly, this Court makes its ruling based on the evidence presented at trial, the Commonwealth’s post-trial brief, and Defendants’ closing argument at trial.
Facts
The Commonwealth claims that Defendants, i.e. ProNurses and Valerie Bester, submitted 236 fraudulent invoices to the Commonwealth and/ or its agencies for payment under a contract. See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 4:4-16, May 26, 2015. The Commonwealth presented testimony from Christine Nichols, a contract administrator for the Commonwealth’s Department of General Services (“DOS”). See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 11:20-12:19. Through Ms. Nichols, the Commonwealth entered into evidence the contract between the Commonwealth and ProNurses. See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 16:3-10. The contract dictates that ProNurses is entitled to payment from the Commonwealth equal to what ProNurses paid its employees plus 10%. See Plaintiff’s Ex. 5. Ms. Nichols testified that Defendants submitted 236 invoices which requested payment of more than what ProNurses paid its employees plus 10%. See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 32:15-34:10; Plaintiff’s Ex. 6 & 7. Ms. Nichols *198concluded at the end of her testimony that ProNurses had overbilled the Commonwealth by $147,206.92. Trial Tr., 49:16-50:6.
Ms. Nichols then testified regarding several monthly detailed usage reports (“MDURs”). See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 35:9-14. These reports gathered the total time ProNurses’ employees worked for the Commonwealth and its agencies and also how much Defendants billed for these employees. See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 39:16-40:5. Defendants would then have to pay the Commonwealth’s DOS 2% of the value billed as a surcharge. See Trial Tr., vol. 1, 40:2-3.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit