Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit December 16, 2015, No. 15-30066 (Schiro v. Office Depot, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-2015

JERRY E. SMITH, Circuit Judge: *

Office Depot, Incorporated (“Office Depot”), and its plan administrator, Sedgwick *967Claims Management Services, Incorporated (“Sedgwick”), appeal a judgment that Sedgwick abused its discretion in denying Alvin Schiro’s short-term disability benefits claim. Because the denial was supported by substantial evidence, and the district court imposed a “treating physician” rule that is inappropriate in the context of plans covered by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”), we reverse and render judgment in favor of Office Depot and Sedg-wick.

I.

Office Depot employed Schiro as a store manager, providing him with coverage through its ERISA-governed Short Term Disability Benefits Program (the “Plan”), which replaces an employee’s wages while he is “totally disabled,” meaning he cannot perform all of his material and essential duties—the duties normally required that cannot be reasonably omitted, changed, or accommodated. Schiro’s material and essential duties as manager included being able to complete documentation accurately, operate equipment necessary to run the store, freely access all areas of the store, climb a ladder, and move up to fifty pounds. Sedgwick administered the Plan for Office Depot, which delegated to Sedg-wick sole discretion to interpret the Plan and decide claims.1

On April 18, 2012, Dr. Charles Thomas surgically removed a blockage in Schiro’s colon. On April 27, Sedgwick notified Schiro that he was required to support his benefits claim with medical evidence by May 10. Schiro missed the deadline— causing Sedgwick tentatively to deny benefits—but submitted office-visit notes from Thomas on May 15 stating that Schiro would be disabled until June 12. After Sedgwick’s internal medical personnel reviewed Thomas’s notes, Sedgwick approved Schiro’s- claims through May 31 under the Plan’s guidelines.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.