District Court, D. New Hampshire January 26, 2016, 15-cv-291-LM (James J. Carney, et al. v. Town of Weare, et al.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-01-2016

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

James J. Carney

Tracy Carney

v. Civil No. 15-cv-291-LM

Opinion No. 2016 DNH 017

Town of Weare, et al

O R D E R

James J. Carney and Tracy Carney bring suit against the

Town of Weare, its elected officials, and several of its police

officers, alleging state and federal claims arising from James’s

employment as an officer in the Weare Police Department.

Defendants have moved to dismiss the Carneys’ amended complaint

for failure to comply with Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 8

and 12(f). Plaintiffs object.

Background

James J. Carney worked as a police officer in various

positions at the Weare Police Department (the “WPD”) from

December 1992 through July 1, 2013, which is the date when

Carney alleges the WPD constructively discharged him. In

response to this alleged discharge and other events that

occurred during his employment, Carney brings federal civil

rights claims and state claims against 14 defendants, including

WPD officers, Weare elected officials, and the Town of Weare.

In addition, Tracy Carney, James’s wife, brings a claim against

defendants for loss of consortium.

The Carneys’ claims are premised on three central

allegations: (1) that defendants harmed Carney by propagating

false statements about him; (2) that defendants sexually

harassed Carney and retaliated against him for reporting that

harassment; and (3) that defendants violated Carney’s

constitutional rights and created an intolerable work

environment for him during an investigation into his alleged

misconduct.

The Carneys originally brought these allegations in a

complaint filed in state court that was 71 pages long and

contained 482 paragraphs. A subset of defendants removed the

action to this court. Meanwhile, counsel for defendants asked

the Carneys’ counsel to consider amending the original complaint

because of its length, its inclusion of extraneous matter, and

its references to personnel files and WPD internal

investigations.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.