Supreme Court of Pennsylvania February 16, 2016, 31 EM 2014 (W. Phila A.C.E. Sch. v. S.D. of Phila.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-02-2016

[J-1-2016] [MO: Saylor, C.J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

EASTERN DISTRICT

WEST PHILADELPHIA ACHIEVEMENT : No. 31 EM 2014

CHARTER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL, :

:

Petitioner :

:

:

v. :

:

:

THE SCHOOL DISTRICT OF :

PHILADELPHIA AND SCHOOL REFORM :

COMMISSION, :

: ARGUED: September 9, 2014

Respondents : RESUBMITTED: January 20, 2016

DISSENTING OPINION

MR. JUSTICE BAER DECIDED: February 16, 2016

I respectfully dissent from the majority’s holding that Section 6-696(i)(3) of the

Distress Law, 24 P.S. § 6-696(i)(3), which grants the School Reform Commission

(“SRC”) the power to suspend provisions of the Public School Code, constitutes an

unlawful delegation of legislative authority in violation of Article II, Section 1 of the

Pennsylvania Constitution.1 In my view, Section 6-696(i)(3) does not delegate

legislative power, but rather delegates the authority to suspend legislation that affects

the economic stability of a school district in financial distress, which is constitutionally

1

This provision, entitled, “Legislative power,” states “[t]he legislative power of this

Commonwealth shall be vested in a General Assembly, which shall consist of a Senate

and a House of Representatives.” PA. CONST. art. II, § 1.

permissible pursuant to Article I, Section 12.2 Accordingly, I would reject the

constitutional challenge raised by the West Philadelphia Achievement Charter School

(“Charter School”) and deny the Charter School’s request for injunctive relief.

Preliminarily, it is relevant that the Distress Law embodies a comprehensive

statutory scheme to preserve school districts that are experiencing a financial crisis by

remediating identified types of economic hardship that have resulted from ordinary

operating procedures under the Public School Code. The statute identifies several

threshold circumstances and levels of fiscal hardship that trigger the Secretary of

Education’s ability to issue a certificate declaring a school district in financial distress.

24 P.S. § 6-691.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.