Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 23, 2016, 16609 1191/13 (People v. Davis)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-2016

— Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Charles H. Solomon, J., at severance motion; Juan M. Merchan, J., at suppression hearing, jury trial and sentencing), rendered February 19, 2014, convicting defendant of robbery in the second and third degrees, assault in the second degree, grand larceny in the fourth degree, and eight counts of criminal possession of stolen property in the fourth degree, and sentencing him to an aggregate term of nine years, affirmed.

Renwick, J.P., and Moskowitz, J., concur in a separate memorandum by Renwick, J.P., as follows: Contrary to the

*560

view taken by Justice Andrias’s concurrence, defendant’s present challenge to the joinder under CPL 200.20 (2) (c) is preserved. Defendant’s motion is understood to seek severance on discretionary grounds as an alternative to severance for improper joinder pursuant to CPL 200.20 (2) (c). More importantly, in opposing defendant’s motion for severance, the People argued that the subject counts were properly joined under CPL 200.20 (2) (c), and the motion court explicitly denied the motion on the ground that the requirements of the subdivision were met.

Under the principles set forth in

People v Pierce

(14 NY3d 564, 573-574 [2010]), the motion court should have granted defendant’s motion to sever the counts charging possession of stolen property, relating to eight stolen MetroCards, from the other counts of the indictment, relating to an assault and robbery. The counts were not properly joined under CPL 200.20 (2) (c), because they were not “similar in law,” except to the extent that “both offenses involve misappropriated property,” which does not suffice

{id.

at 574). Although the counts at issue here are more closely connected, factually, than were the counts in

Pierce,

we reject the People’s argument that this difference warrants a different result under the statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.