New Mexico Court of Appeals March 28, 2016, Docket 33,850 (Eldorado Community Improvement Ass'n v. Billings)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-03-2016

1 IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO

2 Opinion Number: ___________

3 Filing Date: March 28, 2016

4 NO. 33,850

5 ELDORADO COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT

6 ASSOCIATION, INC.,

7 Plaintiff-Appellee,

8 v.

9 SUSAN BILLINGS, DAVID BORTON,

10 DEVRA BORTON, and ERIC WILSON,

11 Defendants-Appellants,

12 and

13 GREG COLELLO, ROSE WINSTON, and

14 GERSHON N. SIEGEL,

15 Defendants.

16 APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF SANTA FE COUNTY

17 Mark A. Macaron, District Judge

18 Cassutt, Hays & Friedman, P.A.

19 John P. Hays

20 Santa Fe, NM

21 for Appellee

1 VanAmberg, Rogers, Yepa, Abeita, Gomez & Works, LLP

2 Ronald J. VanAmberg

3 Santa Fe, NM

4 for Appellants

1 OPINION

2 SUTIN, Judge.

3 {1} This case pits a subdivision association against several subdivision residents

4 who keep hens as pets. The dispute is over a subdivision covenant that disallows

5 “animals, birds, or poultry” on residents’ lots unless kept as “recognized household

6 pets.” The subdivision association sued the defendant hen owners to rid their

7 properties of hens. The defendants (the owners) claimed that their hens met the

8 recognized household pet exception. On motions for summary judgment, the district

9 court agreed with the subdivision association and required the owners to remove their

10 hens from their lots. In this Opinion, we at times refer to “chickens” and to “hens” but

11 we also use “poultry,” because “poultry” appears in Section 11 of the subdivision

12 covenants and because the parties concentrate on using “poultry” in their briefs. We

13 hold that the restrictive covenant does not disallow the owners from keeping hens that

14 are recognized as household pets and that the district court erred in requiring the

15 owners to remove the hens.

16 BACKGROUND

17 {2} Eldorado at Santa Fe Subdivision is a residential development located in Santa

18 Fe County, New Mexico, and was established in 1972 with protective covenants. The

19 1972 covenants stated that their purpose “is to perpetuate . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.