Supreme Court of Missouri April 5, 2016, SC95283 (State ex rel. City of Grandview, Missouri, Relator v. The Honorable Jack R. Grate)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-04-2016

SUPREME COURT OF MISSOURI

en banc

STATE ex rel. CITY OF )

GRANDVIEW, MISSOURI )

)

Relator, )

)

v. ) No. SC95283

)

THE HONORABLE JACK R. GRATE, )

)

Respondent. )

ORIGINAL PROCEEDING IN PROHIBITION

Opinion issued April 5, 2016

Michael Green Sr., Stephanie M. Green, Stephanie N. Green, and Michael Green

(collectively "Plaintiffs") filed a lawsuit, in the underlying case, against four police

officers and the City of Grandview. The City filed a motion for summary judgment

claiming sovereign immunity. The circuit court overruled the motion, and the City

sought a writ of prohibition from the court of appeals that was denied. The City then

sought a writ of prohibition from this Court. This Court issued a preliminary writ of

prohibition that it now makes permanent.

Facts and Procedural Background

Plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against four City of Grandview police officers alleging

wrongful arrest, battery, malicious prosecution and negligence. Plaintiffs joined the City

in the suit, alleging the City was vicariously liable for the actions of the officers.

Specifically, Plaintiffs alleged the City had purchased an insurance policy that contained

a provision for law enforcement liability coverage. This coverage, the Plaintiffs asserted,

waived the City's rights to sovereign immunity and allowed it to be sued up to the policy

limits, pursuant to §§ 71.185, RSMo 2000, and 537.610. 1

The City—in lieu of filing an answer to Plaintiff's petition—filed a motion for

summary judgment claiming that, while it had insurance coverage, the insurance policy it

had purchased contained express language preserving its sovereign immunity, except as

to those claims that sovereign immunity is already waived by statute i.e., claims

involving injuries resulting from the negligent operation of motor vehicles, or injuries

resulting from dangerous conditions on government property. Section 537.600. The

circuit court overruled the motion for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.