Supreme Court of Arkansas April 28, 2016, CV-15-828 (Arkansas State Police v. Wren)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-04-2016

combined-opinion

Cite as 2016 Ark. 188

SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS.

No. CV-15-828

ARKANSAS STATE POLICE and Opinion Delivered April 28, 2016

BILL SADLER, in his official capacity as

custodian of records for the APPEAL FROM THE PULASKI

ARKANSAS STATE POLICE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT

APPELLANTS [60CV-15-2303]

V. HONORABLE MORGAN E.

WELCH, JUDGE

DANIEL E. WREN

APPELLEE AFFIRMED.

ROBIN F. WYNNE, Associate Justice

The Arkansas State Police and Bill Sadler, in his official capacity as custodian of

records for the Arkansas State Police (collectively, the ASP), appeal from a Pulaski County

Circuit Court order granting appellee Daniel Wren relief on his complaint for unredacted

access to certain accident reports under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). The ASP

argues that the circuit court erred in holding that its policy of redacting personal information

from accident reports is a violation of FOIA; the ASP contends that the redacted information

is exempted from disclosure because its disclosure is prohibited by the federal Driver’s

Privacy Protection Act. We affirm.

The parties stipulated to several facts before the circuit court. Appellee, an attorney,

requested to inspect accident reports obtained by Troop A of the ASP from May 1, 2015,

through May 21, 2015. His reason for requesting the accident reports was to search for and

solicit potential clients for his law practice. The parties agreed that the accident reports are

public records as defined by FOIA and that pursuant to Arkansas Code Annotated section

Cite as 2016 Ark. 188

27-53-202(b)(2)(B) (Supp. 2013)1 the name and address of any minor should be redacted

from the reports. At issue before the circuit court was whether the Driver’s Privacy

Protection Act (DPPA) applied to the personal information contained in the accident

reports, as ASP contended.2 ASP’s policy, effective January 1, 2015, required redaction of

personal identifying information unless one of the fourteen DPPA exceptions applies.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.