Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas November 23, 2016, PD-0967-15 (Acosta, Genaro Galvan Jr.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-11-2016

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

OF TEXAS

NO. PD-0967-15

GENARO GALVAN ACOSTA, JR., Appellant

v.

THE STATE OF TEXAS

ON STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW

FROM THE THIRTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS

LIVE OAK COUNTY

J OHNSON, J., filed a concurring opinion in which A LCALÁ, J., joined.

CONCURRING OPINION

This Court has rejected the “divide and conquer” analysis in sufficiency challenges,1 but such

a position does not give free rein to courts to rely on assertions that any and all conduct displayed

by a suspect constitutes “consciousness of guilt.” The court of appeals was at least partially correct

in pointing out that some of the “incriminating” evidence has no clear association with criminal

activity.

The opinion of the Court sets out twelve circumstances that it maintains show appellant’s

1

Smith v. State, 332 S.W .3d 425, 442 (Tex. Crim. App. 2011).

2

affirmative links to criminal activity. Some of the twelve circumstances have a potential to do that,

but some apply to many drivers that have no connection to criminal activity, and for most of those

circumstances, no explanation of why they were clear indicators of an affirmative link to the

contraband was given.

1.

The officers testified that appellant was “unusually” nervous and jittery.2 Most motorists

who are stopped by law enforcement will be nervous to some degree; such persons include me and

my husband, a retired police officer. And appellant was stopped while driving on an invalid license

and having numerous outstanding tickets and carrying passengers who were in violation of seat-belt

laws. This is a maybe/maybe not indicator.

2.

I am unable to discern why the circumstance of “he would not stop talking” is an indicator

of guilt. Some people talk when they are nervous, others clam up.3 We are not given much insight

2

Q. You also testified that you were trained as to what’s considered "ordinary" on a traffic stop versus what’s

not considered ordinary?

A. [Trooper Prado] Yes, ma’am.

Q.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.