Superior Court of Pennsylvania January 4, 2016 (M.L. v. J.G.M.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-01-2016

OPINION BY

LAZARUS, J.:

M.L., (“Mother”), appeals from the trial court’s order granting J.G.M.’s motion for blood tests to determine paternity pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 5104(c).1 J.G.M. *1007filed a motion to quash Mother’s appeal, which we deny.2 After our review, we vacate and remand.

Mother and J.G.M. were married on July 11,2001. They are the parents of one child, a daughter, (“E.M.”), born in July 2005. Mother and J.G.M. separated in December 2011, and they divorced in September 2014.

When the parties separated, J.G.M. began to question his paternity. He administered a home “DNA” test, which excluded him as E.M.’s father. Thereafter, on September 11, 2013, he filed a petition to terminate support, alleging that upon learning he might not be E.M.’s biological father, he terminated his relationship with her. Mother filed an answer, requesting the court deny J.G.M.’s petition. J.G.M. sought a psychological evaluation of E.M. for the purpose of evaluating the bond between him and E.M. The court ordered the evaluation and, following testing, J.G.M. filed a motion for blood tests to determine paternity pursuant to section 5104(c). The trial court granted the motion, but did so prior to determining whether the doctrine of paternity by estop-pel applied. See Jones v. Trojak, 535 Pa. 95, 634 A.2d 201, 206 (1993) (where paternity by estoppel principle is operative, “blood tests may well be irrelevant.”).

On appeal, Mother argues that the doctrine of paternity by estoppel should- apply.in this case, thus precluding paternity testing under section 5104.3

Paternity by estoppel'“is merely the legal determination that because of a person’s conduct (e.g., holding the child out as his own or supporting the child), that person, regárdless of‘his true biological status, will not be permitted to deny parentage'[.]” B.K.B. v. J.G.K., 954 A.2d 630, 634 (Pa.Super.2008).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.