Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas January 13, 2016, PD-0509-14 (Marshall v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-01-2016
lead-opinion
OPINION
KEASLER, J.,
delivered the opinion of the Court
in which JOHNSON, HERVEY, ALCALA, RICHARDSON, and NEWELL, JJ., joined.
A jury convicted Patrick Marshall of felony assault against a family member. On appeal, the court of appeals held the evidence legally sufficient but the omission of the words “bodily injury” from the jury charge's application paragraph egregiously harmed Marshall.1 Wé agree that the evidence was sufficient, but disagree that the jury charge egregiously harmed Marshall because the jury charge sufficiently required the jury to find bodily injury by impeding normal breathing — a bodily injury per se. We therefore reverse the judgment below.
I. Facts and Procedural History
While the parties do not dispute the facts, a brief background is necessary. On September 5, 2005, Marshall and his wife, Shawne Marshall physically fought. The fight moved into the bedroom where Marshall pushed Shawne onto the bed. -He straddled her and put a pillow over her face, holding down each side of the pillow. Shawne testified- that his body weight pinned her to the bed and the pillow affected her breathing. She further testified that she never passed out and never lost the complete ability to breathe. Nevertheless, she testified that she could not take deep breaths. The jury charge instructed the jury to return a guilty verdict if they found
that the defendant, Patrick James Marshall, ... did then and there intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly impede the normal breathing or circulation of the blood of Shawne Marshall by blocking , the nose or mouth of Shawne Marshall with a pillow, and the said Shawne Marshall was then and there a member of the defendant’s family or household.
Marshall’s trial counsel did not object to the omission of “bodily injury.” The jury convicted Marshall under Penal Code § 22.01, felony assault against a family member. Penal Code § 22.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit