District Court, D. Connecticut March 23, 2016, CIVIL CASE NUMBER: 3:05-cv-01975-VLB (ProBatter Sports, LLC v. Sports Tutor, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-03-2016
MEMORANDUM OF DECISION
Hon." Vanessa L. Bryant, United States District" Judge
Plaintiff ProBatter Sports, LLC (“Pro-Batter”), a Connecticut business designing, manufacturing, selling, installing, and servicing pitching .machines, produces a three-wheeled machine called ProBatter Simulator. ProBatter Simulator, which has been sold to professional baseball teams, professional baseball players, and colleges, simulates a real-at-bat experience by generating almost.any pitch within seven to ten seconds. ProBatter Simulator accomplishes this feat by utilizing a combination of technologies including dynamic braking, a programmable controller, and horizontal and vertical linear actuators. To protect its inventiqn, ProBatter obtained United States Patent. Numbers 6,182,649 and 6,546,924 (“ProBatter Patents”).
Defendant Sports Tutor, Inc. (“Sports Tutor”), a California corporation also involved in the pitching-machine business, manufactures and sells two machines called HomePlate and HomePlate Premier (“HomePlate Machines”). HomePlate Machines similarly employ, inter alia, regenerative braking, a programmable controller, and horizontal and vertical linear actuators to automatically simulate almost any pitch within seven seconds. HomeP-late Machines likewise have been sold to Major League Baseball teams, professional baseball players, and college programs, but they sell for substantially less than ProBatter Simulator. Sports Tutor introduced the HomePlate Machines after the approval of the ProBatter Patents. Sports Tutor does not hold a patent for its Ho-mePlate Machines.
ProBatter brought this action for patent infringement against Sports Tutor. Sports Tutor answered,' in relevant part, that the ProBatter Patents were invalid for obviousness. The Court granted summary judgment on the question of infringement but denied summary judgment on the question of invalidity.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit