District Court, S.D. Georgia April 6, 2016, Case No. CV415-001 (Hamlett v. Carroll Fulmer Logistics Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-04-2016
ORDER
G. R. SMITH, UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
After he returned from his overseas military deployment in 2014, Sergeant First Class Leroy Hamlett crashed his motorcycle into a truck driven by George Swartz and owned by Swartz’s employer, Carroll Fulmer Logistics Corporation (CFLC).1 Doe. 1-1 at 3; doc. 55 at 4. Georgia State Patrol Trooper Robert L. Scott, Jr. examined the scene just after the accident and found Swartz at fault. The crash occurred on a' four-lane road in Richmond Hill, Georgia. Hamlett had the right-of-way but Swartz made a left turn from his oncoming lane, causing Hamlett to collide with his truck’s front end. See doc. 37-2 at 89 (official accident report diagram). Scott issued an O.C.G.A. § 40-6-73 (failure to yield) citation to Swartz, who paid the fine. Doc. 1-1 at 3; doc, 55' at 4; doc. 68 at 13. Hamlett and his wife (consortium claim) sued Swartz, CFLC, and CFLC’s insurer. Doc. 1-1.2 He seeks compensatory and pu*1363nitive damages, plus O.C.G.A. § 13-6-11 attorney fees and costs.3 Id.
The defendants move for summary judgment against plaintiffs punitive damage and attorney fee claims. Docs. 34, 35 & 40. They also move to exclude expert witness Jeffrey Alan Kidd’s testimony about his calculations and diagrams because he failed to produce them with his written report by the Court’s disclosure deadline. Doc. 38, Finally, they move to exclude from trial Scott’s testimony on these topics: whether Hamlett was a cause of the accident; the percentage of Swartz’s fault; whether Hamlett should have avoided Swartz’s tractor trailer; and Hamlett’s alleged speed at impact. Doc. 37. The summary judgment motions are before the district judge. The exclusion motions are reached here.
I. ANALYSIS
A. Kidd’s Testimony
Hamlett hired Kidd as an accident reconstruction expert who, unsurprisingly, lays all the blame on Swartz. Doc. 25 at 3.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit