District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania June 17, 2016, CIVIL ACTION No. 14-980 (Estate of Goldberg ex rel. Goldberg v. Nimoityn)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-2016

MEMORANDUM

Gerald Austin McHugh, United States District Court Judge

This is a medical negligence action governed by Pennsylvania law brought under the Court’s diversity jurisdiction. The crux of the action is an allegation that the individual Defendant, Philip Nimoityn, M.D., wrongfully refused to arrange for the implantation of a feeding tube as his patient, Bernice Goldberg, deteriorated, resulting in her premature death. There are also allegations of “corporate” negligence on the part of Defendant Thomas Jefferson University Hospital (“Jefferson”), both with respect to the hiring of the individual Defendant, and with respect to the practices of its residents.

There is a global Motion for Summary Judgment advancing an argument that Plaintiffs expert is not competent to testify under Pennsylvania’s MCARE Act because he presently lacks board certification in a case where the Defendant physician is board certified. There is also a subsidiary Motion for Summary Judgment seeking dismissal of the corporate negligence claims against Jefferson, as well as Plaintiffs claim for punitive damages.

Because the MCARE Act permits a physician who is not board certified but is otherwise qualified to opine on the standard of care, the global Motion for Summary Judgment will be denied, but the direct claim against Jefferson and the claim for punitive damages will be dismissed.

I. Facts

Mrs. Goldberg was 81 years old when she arrived at the Jefferson Emergency Room on August 11, 2011, complaining of chest pain. She suffered from several serious medical conditions including a history of COPD, diabetes, coronary artery disease, congestive heart failure, and suspected. pancreatic cancer. Doghramji Report, Def. Ex. E at 5. She had been admitted to Jefferson several times in the months leading up to this admission, and her mental capacity was questioned and tested on several of those prior occasions. Lamsback Report, Def. Ex. C at 3.

Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.