Texas Court of Appeals, 10th District (Waco) January 11, 2017, 10-15-00273-CV (Annette Knopf and Stanley Gray v. William R. Gray, Karen A. Gray and Polasek Farms, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-01-2017

IN THE

TENTH COURT OF APPEALS

No. 10-15-00273-CV

ANNETTE KNOPF AND STANLEY GRAY,

Appellants

v.

WILLIAM R. GRAY, KAREN A. GRAY AND

POLASEK FARMS, LLC,

Appellees

From the 82nd District Court

Robertson County, Texas

Trial Court No. 14-09-19619-CV

DISSENTING OPINION

The issue herein is a question of fact that is not appropriate for disposition by

summary judgment. There is no mistaking what the testator wanted to do. She was quite

clear about that. The question is whether she accomplished on paper what she did within

her mind. And the Court recognizes that the proper question is what did the testator

intend. It is clear she was working from copies of at least two different wills. And for

every interpretation of a word or phrase the Court mentions to support their conclusion,

I could offer a different interpretation of the same word or phrase based upon the content

of the will that would support a different understanding and result. But I can

count. There are two votes to affirm the trial court and only one to reverse. There is thus

nothing to be gained by going through a lengthy interpretative analysis in this type

proceeding in which I agree with virtually every statement of what the law is, but

disagree with the manner in which that law is applied. The point is that if there are two

logical interpretations upon which admissible facts would be relevant, and I believe there

is, it is not proper to resolve the issue by summary judgment.

I must, however, comment on the trial court’s determination of a disabling

restraint, generally referred to as an unreasonable restraint on alienation, that seems to

have been the basis of the trial court’s determination that disposition by summary

judgment was proper. This doctrine has its genesis in the year 1290 with the passage of

the Quia Emptores, but has no application in this case. As noted by the Court, the trial

court found the relevant clause involved a disabling restraint which was void.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.