Court of Appeals of Washington January 17, 2017, 76032-7 (State Of Washington v. Jose Villareal, Jr.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-01-2017

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

STATE OF WASHINGTON, )

) DIVISION ONE

Respondent, )

) No. 76032-7-I >

rri

v. ) C.7

) UNPUBLISHED OPINION

JOSE AUSTINE VILLAREAL, JR., ) ---- -urn

(i) rn '

)

(-

Appellant. ) FILED: January 17, 2017 27

)

DWYER, J. — Jose Villareal, Jr. appeals from the judgment entered on a

jury's verdict finding him guilty of five counts of felony violation of a

postconviction no-contact order. He contends that the trial court erred by

admitting five redacted jail telephone recordings. The State alleged that the

recordings were of conversations between Villareal and the protected party,

Kristin Carter. Villareal asserts that the recordings were not properly

authenticated. We conclude to the contrary.

Villareal also contends, and the State concedes, that his conviction for one

count of felony violation of a postconviction no-contact order was not supported

by sufficient evidence. We accept this concession and remand for vacation of

count six, and resentencing, within the trial court's discretion, on the remaining

convictions. The judgment of guilt on the other four counts stands.

No. 76032-7-1/2

I

Villareal was charged with seven counts of felony violation of a

postconviction no-contact order, pursuant to RCW 26.50.110(5), which makes

violation of a no-contact order a class C felony if the offender has at least two

previous convictions for violating an order issued under that chapter. At the time,

Villareal had two prior convictions for such violations.

At trial, over Villareal's objection, the trial court admitted into evidence five

recorded telephone conversations that the State alleged were between Villareal

and Carter. Community Corrections Officer Maria Cumero—who had previously

met Villareal and had spoken to Carter on the telephone on several occasions—

testified that the individuals on the recordings sounded like Villareal and Carter.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.