New Mexico Court of Appeals January 24, 2017, 34,667 (State v. Navarro-Calzadillas)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-01-2017

1 IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO

2 Opinion Number: _______________

3 Filing Date: January 24, 2017

4 NO. 34,667

5 STATE OF NEW MEXICO,

6 Plaintiff-Appellant,

7 v.

8 ARMANDO NAVARRO-CALZADILLAS,

9 Defendant-Appellee.

10 APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF BERNALILLO COUNTY

11 Jacqueline D. Flores, District Judge

12 Hector H. Balderas, Attorney General

13 Santa Fe, NM

14 for Appellant

15 Garcia Ives Nowara

16 Zachary A. Ives

17 Molly Schmidt-Nowara

18 Albuquerque, NM

19 for Appellee

1 OPINION

2 HANISEE, Judge.

3 {1} The State appeals from the district court’s April 2, 2015 order granting

4 Defendant Armando Navarro-Calzadillas’s motion to exclude witnesses. Because this

5 matter is governed by the special calendar portion of LR2-400 NMRA (2014)1, the

6 case management pilot rule in the Second Judicial District Court (the local rule), see

7 LR2-400(L) (2014); LR2-400.1 NMRA, and given this Court’s concerns with

8 reconciling the requirements of the local rule with Supreme Court precedent that

9 places limitations on the district court’s discretion, we certified this matter to our

10 Supreme Court. The Supreme Court quashed certification and directed our attention

11 to specific language contained in LR2-400(A) (2014), adding that “the Court is

12 confident that the Court of Appeals is fully capable of applying this Court’s textual

13 direction in . . . that prior procedural precedents apply to cases governed by the [local]

14 rule only ‘to the extent they do not conflict with’ [the local rule.]” Having now

15 examined applicable provisions of the local rule alongside the clear directives of State

16 v. Harper, 2011-NMSC-044, ¶ 16, 150 N.M. 745, 266 P.3d 25 (requiring a trial

17 court’s consideration of lesser sanctions in certain circumstances), we reverse.

1

18 Pursuant to Supreme Court Order No. 16-8300-015, former LR2-400 (2014)

19 was recompiled and amended as LR2-308 NMRA, effective December 31, 2016.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.