Court of Appeals of Washington February 21, 2017, 75021-6 (Heidi Morgan v. Michel Hebert)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-2017

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

HEIDI MORGAN, an unmarried individual, •)

) No. 75021-6-1

Appellant, )

) DIVISION ONE

v. )

) UNPUBLISHED OPINION

MICHAEL B. HEBERT and JANE DOE )

HEBERT, husband and wife and the )

marital community thereof; WILLIAM )

HEBERT and MARIA HEBERT, husband )

and wife and the marital community )

composed thereof, )

)

Respondents. ) FILED: February 21, 2017

)

APPELWICK, J. — Michael took his parents' vehicle without permission.

They demanded that he return it. Morgan argues that Michael was his parents'

agent when he negligently collided with her vehicle while he was returning the

car as directed. The trial court dismissed Morgan's claims against the parents on

summary judgment. We affirm.

FACTS

This case arises out of a motor vehicle accident involving Michael Hebert

and Heidi Morgan. Michael's parents, William and Maria Hebert, owned the

No. 75021-6-1/2

vehicle that Michael was driving. 1 Michael was an adult at the time of the

accident. He did not live with his parents. Michael described his relationship

with his parents as "not the best." But, Michael would occasionally visit his

parents' house and was permitted to stay the night. Michael's parents had made

very clear to him that he could not use their 1994 Infinity J304D vehicle. Michael

also had a suspended driver's license. But, on May 23 or 24, 2014, while his

parents were gone, Michael took the Infinity.

When they discovered that the vehicle was missing, the parents did not

immediately report the car stolen. They suspected that Michael had taken it.

William immediately called Michael. He demanded that Michael return the

vehicle. Maria specifically remembered William telling Michael to "[Met the car

home." Over the next few days, the parents called Michael and sent him multiple

text messages asking him to return the vehicle. They threatened to notify the

police.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.