Supreme Court of Pennsylvania June 20, 2017, Yenchi, E. v. Ameriprise Financial, Aplts. - No. 8 WAP 2016 (Yenchi, E. v. Ameriprise Financial, Aplts.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-06-2017

[J-102-2016] [MO: Donohue, J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

WESTERN DISTRICT

EUGENE R. YENCHI AND RUTH I. : No. 8 WAP 2016

YENCHI, HUSBAND AND WIFE,

: Appeal from the Order of the Superior

Appellees : Court entered September 15, 2015 at

: No. 753 WDA 2014, vacating the

: Judgment of the Court of Common

v. : Pleas of Allegheny County entered May

: 5, 2014 at No. GD 01-006610, and

: remanding.

AMERIPRISE FINANCIAL, INC.,

AMERIPRISE FINANCIAL SERVICES, : ARGUED: November 1, 2016

INC., RIVERSOURCE LIFE INSURANCE

COMPANY AND BRYAN GREGORY

HOLLAND,

Appellants

DISSENTING OPINION

JUSTICE TODD DECIDED: JUNE 20, 2017

I dissent because, unlike the majority, I find there are sufficient indicators of a

fiduciary relationship between the Yenchis and Appellants to allow the Yenchis to avoid

summary judgment on their fiduciary duty claim. For the following reasons, I would

affirm the Superior Court.

As the majority recognizes, outside of the context of fiduciary duties imposed as

a matter of law, the existence of a confidential relationship is, first and foremost, a fact-

driven inquiry. See Basile v. H & R Block, Inc., 52 A.3d 1202, 1210 (Pa. 2012) (noting

"the 'intensely fact -specific' nature of this inquiry"); In re Estate of Scott, 316 A.2d 883,

885 (Pa. 1974) ("The concept of a confidential relationship cannot be reduced to a

catalogue of specific circumstances, invariably falling to the left or right of a definitional

line. . . . [E]ach case must be analyzed on its own facts."). Moreover, the majority cites

the governing test which we have reiterated for finding a confidential relationship: "[A]

confidential relationship 'appears when the circumstances make it certain the parties do

not deal on equal terms, but, on the one side there is an overmastering influence, or, on

the other, weakness, dependence or trust, justifiably reposed." Majority Opinion at 12

(quoting Frowen v. Blank, 425 A.2d 412, 416-17 (Pa. 1981)).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.