Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces August 30, 2017, 17-0153/AR (United States v. Mitchell)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-08-2017

combined-opinion

This opinion is subject to revision before publication

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE ARMED FORCES

_______________

UNITED STATES

Appellant

v.

Edward J. MITCHELL II, Sergeant

United States Army, Appellee

No. 17-0153

Crim. App. No. 20150776

Argued April 4, 2017—Decided August 30, 2017

Military Judge: Rebecca K. Connally

For Appellant: Captain Samuel E. Landes (argued); Colo-

nel Mark H. Sydenham and Lieutenant Colonel A. G.

Courie III (on brief); Major Anne C. Hsieh.

For Appellee: Captain Joshua B. Fix (argued); Lieutenant

Colonel Christopher D. Carrier and Captain Katherine L.

DePaul (on brief); Major Andres Vazquez Jr.

Amici Curiae for Appellant: Colonel Katherine E. Oler,

Major Mary Ellen Payne, and Gerald R. Bruce, Esq. (on

brief)—for Air Force Appellate Government Division.

Sean Patrick Flynn (law student) (argued); Alyssa

Hughes (law student), Jimmy Gurulé, Esq. (supervising

attorney), and Marah McLeod, Esq. (supervising attor-

ney) (on brief)—Notre Dame Law School.

Amici Curiae for Appellee: Jamie Williams, Esq., and

Mark Rumold, Esq. (Electronic Frontier Foundation);

Brett Max Kaufman, Esq., and Patrick Toomey, Esq.

(American Civil Liberties Union); and Arthur B. Spitzer,

Esq, and Scott Michelman, Esq. (ACLU of the District of

Columbia) (on brief)—for Electronic Frontier Founda-

tion, American Civil Liberties Union, and ACLU of the

District of Columbia. Dominic X. Barceleau (law stu-

dent) (argued); Stephen F. Smith, Esq. (supervising at-

torney) (on brief)—Notre Dame Law School.

Chief Judge STUCKY delivered the opinion of the

Court, in which Judges OHLSON and SPARKS, and

Senior Judge ERDMANN, joined. Judge RYAN filed a

separate dissenting opinion.

_______________

This opinion is subject to revision before publication

Chief Judge STUCKY delivered the opinion of the Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.