Kentucky Supreme Court October 24, 2017, 2014 SC 000512 (Aep Industries Inc. v. B.G. Properties, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-10-2017

RENDERED: SEPTEMBER 28, 201 i

TO BE PUBLISHED

2014-SC-000512-DG [Q)~IJ~lcJ/tctfr-, ft,M f2ad""°"''~

AEP INDUSTRIES, INC. APPELLANT

ON REVIEW FROM COURT OF APPEALS

v. CASE NO. 2013-CA-000132

WARREN CIRCUIT COURT NO. 12-CI-00467

B.G. PROPERTIES, INC. APPELLEE

OPINION OF THE COURT BY JUSTICE VENTERS ·

\I

VACATING AND REMANDING

AEP Industries, Inc. (AEP) appeals from an opinion of the Court of

Appeals which vacated a final order of the Warren Circuit Court granting AEP's

motion for specific· performance of a real estate option contract between AEP

and B.G. Properties, Inc. (BG). The Court of Appeals held that the circuit court

granted specific performance ofthe option contract prematurely because

disputed issues of fact material to that form of relief had been left unresolved in

the 'circuit court. The Courtof Appeals remanded the matter for resolution of·

those issues. We granted discretionary review, and upon. review .we vacate the

opinion of the Court of Appeals and remand the action to the trial court with

direction to dismiss any remaining claims.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND·

BG and its predecessor in interest owned an industrial building located

on a 19.7-acre tract in Bowling Green, Kentucky. The building had been used

for manufacturing flexible plastic packing products and contained features

uniquely suited to that purpose. AEP leased .the property from BG for use in

its business of manufacturing flexible plastic packaging. AEP arid BG were

mutUally obligated under several agreements concerning the property. Those

agreements provided AEP with an option to purchase the property.I

The specific terms of .the purchase option are provided in two documents:

the "Consent to Assignment of Lease and Grant of Option to. Purchase" made in

2001 and the "Agreement Modifying Sublease and Option" made iri 2010.

These two documents collectively provide the terms of AEP's option to purchase

·the property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.