Court of Special Appeals of Maryland November 1, 2017, 1460/16 (Sugarman v. Liles)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-2017

HEADNOTE:

Stanley Sugarman, et al. v. Chauncey Liles, Jr., No. 1460, September Term, 2016.

SUFFICIENCY OF EVIDENCE; EXPERT TESTIMONY; EPIDEMOLOGICAL

STUDIES

Epidemiological studies indicating a causal relationship between childhood lead exposure

and problems with attention, in conjunction with Mr. Liles’ medical and

neurophysiological records, provided a sufficient factual basis for the circuit court to permit

the jury to consider whether Mr. Liles’ cognitive impairments in processing speed and

auditory encoding, measures of attention, were caused by lead exposure. And, the expert’s

opinion, based on the Lanpher Study, that the plaintiff lost four IQ points as a result of lead

exposure, had a sufficient factual basis.

Additionally, there was a sufficient basis for testimony indicating that Mr. Liles would

suffer a loss of earning capacity in the amount of $1,698,808. Dr. Conte, an economics

expert, explained that this amount reflected the difference between the wages an individual

could receive if he or she were able to attain an Associate’s degree (plaintiff’s earning

potential absent injury), i.e., $3,456,127, and the wages of an individual with only high

school education, plus some college (earning capacity with cognitive deficits), i.e.,

$1,757,320. This evidence was sufficient to present the issue of damages to the jury.

Circuit Court for Baltimore City

Case No. 24-C-14-005808

REPORTED

IN THE COURT OF SPECIAL APPEALS

OF MARYLAND

No. 1460

September Term, 2016

______________________________________

STANLEY SUGARMAN, ET AL.

v.

CHAUNCEY LILES, JR.

______________________________________

Graeff,

Friedman,

Thieme, Raymond G., Jr.

(Senior Judge, Specially Assigned),

JJ.

______________________________________

Opinion by Graeff, J.

______________________________________

Filed: November 1, 2017

Chauncey Liles, Jr., appellee, filed a complaint against Ivy Realty, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.