Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 17, 2017, 1191 CA 17-00681 (Bradley v. Konakanchi)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-2017

OPINION OF THE COURT

NeMoyer, J.

We hold that CPLR 3404 does not apply when the note of issue is vacated.

Facts

The material facts are undisputed. Plaintiff’s ward was admitted to the psychiatric unit of a hospital in the City of Niagara Falls. Shortly thereafter, he allegedly jumped off the hospital’s roof and sustained serious physical injuries. Plaintiff subsequently commenced the instant medical malpractice action against, inter alia, Ramesh Konakanchi, D.O. (defendant). Discovery ensued, and plaintiff eventually filed a note of issue. Defendant moved to vacate the note of issue pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.21 (e), arguing that discovery was incomplete. Supreme Court granted the motion, vacated the note of issue, and ordered additional discovery.

Over a year passed without the filing of a new note of issue.

1

Defendant then moved to dismiss the action against him pursuant to CPLR 3404, which provides for the administrative dismissal of inactive cases under certain circumstances. Plaintiff opposed the motion, arguing that CPLR 3404 is categorically inapplicable when the note of issue has been vacated. The court denied the motion, although it acknowledged the “conflicting decisions on the breadth of CPLR Rule 3404” and observed that “appellate clarification on the breadth of Rule 3404 would be instructive.”

Defendant appeals, and we now affirm.

Discussion

This appeal turns entirely on the proper interpretation of CPLR 3404, which says, in full:

“A case in the supreme court or a county court marked ‘off’ or struck from the calendar or unanswered on a clerk’s calendar call, and not restored within one year thereafter, shall be deemed abandoned and shall be dismissed without costs for neglect to prosecute. The clerk shall make an appropriate entry without the necessity of an order.”

Defendant argues that the case was “marked ‘off’ ” or “struck” from the calendar when the court vacated plaintiff’s note of issue. Because plaintiff did not file a new note of issue (i.e.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.