Supreme Court of Pennsylvania November 22, 2017, 64 MAP 2015 (Shoul, L. v. Bureau of Driver Licensing, Aplt.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-11-2017

[J-83-2016] [MO:Todd, J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

MIDDLE DISTRICT

LAWRENCE S. SHOUL, : No. 64 MAP 2015

:

Appellee : Appeal from the Order of the Adams

: County Court of Common Pleas, Civil

: Division, at No. 2014-S-721 dated

v. : February 24, 2015, exited February 26,

: 2015.

:

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, : ARGUED: December 6, 2016

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, :

BUREAU OF DRIVER LICENSING, :

:

Appellant :

CONCURRING AND DISSENTING OPINION

JUSTICE DOUGHERTY DECIDED: November 22, 2017

I agree with the learned majority’s application of the rational basis test as

articulated by this Court in Gambone v. Commonwealth, 101 A.2d 634 (Pa. 1954), and

Nixon v. Commonwealth, 839 A.2d 277 (Pa. 2003), and with its determination that, as a

matter of Pennsylvania constitutional jurisprudence, lifetime disqualification from holding

a commercial driver’s license (“CDL”) as set forth in 75 Pa.C.S. §1611(e)(1) is not

rationally related to promoting highway safety. I respectfully disagree, however, with the

majority’s determination lifetime disqualification ultimately conforms to Pennsylvania

due process requirements because it is rationally related to deterring drug activity. I

respectfully distance myself from the majority’s reliance on Plowman v. Dept. of Tran.,

Bureau of Driver Licensing, 635 A.2d 124 (Pa. 1993), to support its holding in this

regard, and I distance myself from the view expressed in Justice Wecht’s thoughtful

concurring opinion — that the rational basis test in Pennsylvania grants deference to the

legislature greater than that articulated by this Court in Gambone, supra, and Nixon,

supra. Like the well-reasoned majority, I would defer that question to a future case in

which the issue is precisely presented and addressed by the parties and the lower

courts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.