Nevada Supreme Court October 5, 2017, 68053 (MENDENHALL VS. TASSINARI)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-2017

133 Nev., Advance Opinion 76

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA

ROBERT L. MENDENHALL, AN No. 68053

INDIVIDUAL; AND SUNRIDGE

CORPORATION, A NEVADA

CORPORATION,

Appellants,

FILED

vs. OCT 0 5 2017

RONALD TASSINARI, AN

INDIVIDUAL; AND AMERICAN

VANTAGE BROWNSTONE, LLC, A

NEVADA LIMITED LIABILITY

COMPANY,

Respondents.

Appeal from a district court order dismissing a tort action.

Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; Rob Bare, Judge.

Affirmed.

Marquis Aurbach Coffing and Micah S. Echols, Avece M. Higbee, and

Adele V. Karoum, Las Vegas; Howard & Howard Attorneys PLLC and

Gwen Rutar Mullins and Wade B. Gochnour, Las Vegas,

for Appellants.

Santoro Whitmire and Nicholas J. Santoro and Oliver J. Pancheri, Las

Vegas; Harry Paul Marquis, Chtd., and Harry Paul Marquis, Las Vegas;

Legal Offices of James J. Lee and James J. Lee, Las Vegas,

for Respondents.

BEFORE DOUGLAS, GIBBONS and PICKERING, JJ.

SUPREME COURT

OF

NEVADA

(0) 1947A elm

73B,Pq

OPINION

By the Court, DOUGLAS, J.:

This case addresses the tension in the law that arises where a

party that served an NRCP 68 offer of judgment discovers facts, during

the ten-day irrevocable period for acceptance of NRCP 68 offers, that

would otherwise impact the offering party's decision to serve an NRCP 68

offer in the first instance. Specifically, we must determine whether claims

that are brought by the offering party in a second action, and arise out of

these facts that were discovered after serving the NRCP 68 offer, are

barred by general principles of claim preclusion or by the very terms of the

NRCP 68 offer.

We hold that both the general principles of claim preclusion

and the terms in an NRCP 68 offer are implicated where a party seeks to

relitigate claims after entry of a final judgment pursuant to the NRCP 68

offer, even when they arise out of facts discovered during the NRCP 68

offer's ten-day irrevocable period for acceptance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.