District Court of Appeal of Florida May 10, 2017, No. 4D15-4449 (Yerks v. School Board of Broward County)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-05-2017

lead-opinion

Taylor, J.

Appellant, Steven Yerks, a teacher who was discharged primarily for failing to correct alleged performance deficiencies, appeals a final administrative order in which the Broward County School Board rejected certain factual findings of the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) and rejected the ALJ’s recommendation that appellant be reinstated. We reverse.

This dispute arises out of appellant’s performance as a mathematics teacher at Boyd Anderson High School during the 2013-14 school year. At all relevant times, the School Board used a performance evaluation system known as iObservation, which is based on the methods of Dr. Robert Marzano.

The iObservation form consists of 60 strategies or criteria listed in four domains—classroom strategies, planning and preparation, reflecting on teaching, and professionalism. Observers score the criteria in the domains by issuing the following “datamarks” to indicate the teacher's level of performance—innovating (4 points), applying (3 points), developing (2.5 points), beginning (2 points), and not using (1 point).

In February 2014, appellant was placed on a Performance Development Plan. There were 18 observations of appellant’s classroom performance during the school year. Most of the observations were conducted by either the principal or the assis*846tant principal. Over 100 “datamarks” concerning appellant’s teaching performance were entered into the iObservation system during the observations. Appellant’s final score was unsatisfactory.

In June 2014, the Broward County Superintendent of Schools filed an Administrative Complaint recommending that áppellant be terminated from his employment with the school district. The case proceeded to a formal administrative hearing.

At the three-day hearing, the ALJ heard testimony from 16 witnesses and admitted multiple exhibits into evidence, including the 102 datamarks recorded in the performance evaluation system.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.