Court of Appeals of Kentucky May 5, 2017, NO. 2016-CA-000653-ME (Agnich v. Tyler)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-2017

OPINION

JONES, JUDGE:

Jan Agnich appeals from an Order of the Fayette Circuit Court granting La-Donna Tyler’s Motion to Modify Timesharing, permitting her to relocate with the parties’ two minor children to another state. For the reasons set forth below, we vacate and remand for additional proceedings.

I. Background

Appellant, Jan Marie Agnich (“Jan”), and Appellee, LaDonna Kay Tyler (“La-Donna”), were in a committed same-sex relationship for thirteen years. During that time, they decided to begin a family together. After several rounds of in vitro fertilization, LaDonna became pregnant with twins, who were born on June 23, 2010, and are now six years old. The parties resided with the children in Jan’s Lexington home as a family until May of 2015.

Just prior to the birth of the twins, both Jan and LaDonna signed Wills and related estate planning documents. In her Will, LaDonna specifically directed that Jan is to be the guardian of any children she may have. LaDonna’s Will states: “I specifically do not want my parents ... or my brother ... to be the guardian of any minor child(ren) of mine.” LaDonna also signed a “Nomination of Guardian for Estate and Person of a Minor Child” for both children, expressing her desire for Jan to care for the children in the event she became unable to do so. The Nominations further stated that, in the event Jan could not care for the minor children, LaDonna designated Jan’s sister.

In May 2013, both children were diagnosed with autism at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital. After the diagnosis, the parties applied for and received a state Medicaid grant to provide caregivers for the children. Approximately a month later, Jan filed a Verified Petition for Custody. On that same day, LaDonna filed an Affidavit and Consent to Custody. The parties jointly decided and agreed upon this course of action to ensure Jan would have legal parental rights in the event any issues occurred later on in their relationship.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.