Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas June 7, 2017, NOS. WR-85,060-01 & WR-85,060-02 (Ex parte Carter)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-06-2017

lead-opinion

OPINION

Keasler, J.,

delivered the judgment of the Court and an opinion,

in which Keller, P.J., and Hervey, and Yeary, JJ., joined and Newell, J., joined in part.

In these habeas corpus applications, Roger Carter asserts the trial judge improperly cumulated, or “stacked,” his burglary sentence and credit-card-abuse sentences. We filed and set Carter’s applications to address whether his claims are cognizable in a habeas corpus proceeding. Because Carter could have appealed his bare statutory violation and record-based claims, we conclude they are not cognizable and deny Carter’s applications.

I,

In two separate indictments, Carter was charged with burglary of a habitation and two counts of credit card abuse. Each indictment contained enhancement paragraphs. Without a plea bargain with the State, Carter pleaded guilty to all offenses and true to the enhancement paragraphs. Finding the enhancements to be true, the judge sentenced Carter to fifty years’ confinement for the burglary and five years’ confinement for each credit card abuse count. The judge ordered Carter to serve the credit-card-abuse sentences simultaneously, but only after the burglary sentence’s expiration. The court of appeals rejected Carter’s challenges to the judge’s sentencing him as a habitual offender, and it affirmed the judgments.1

Approximately five years after the court of appeals’ mandate issued, Carter filed these applications for writs of habeas corpus asserting that, among other things, his sentences were improperly ordered to run consecutively. This Court remanded Carter’s applications for findings of fact and conclusions of law on this ground.2 The habeas judge found that Carter’s improper-cumulation claim “is based on the record and could have been, but was not, raised on direct appeal.” Because Carter could have raised this claim on direct appeal, the judge concluded that the claim was not cognizable in a habeas corpus proceeding.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.