California Court of Appeal, 5th District July 17, 2017, C079180 (Ponte v. Cnty. of Calaveras)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-07-2017
Duarte, J.
*553Plaintiff Dennis Ponte is asking defendant County of Calaveras (County) to pay him over $150,000 to reimburse him for work purportedly performed on the County's behalf pursuant to an oral contract. The contract did not contain any fixed payment, and no bid was submitted-far less approved-pursuant to relevant county ordinances governing public contracts. Ponte disregarded opportunities to abandon his claims after the County provided him with pertinent legal authority demonstrating that his claims lacked merit. After multiple sustained demurrers, the trial court granted summary judgment to the County on Ponte's third amended complaint. The court later awarded substantial attorney fees, finding Ponte's claims-including those based on promissory estoppel-were not brought or maintained in both subjective and objective good faith.
Ponte appeals. We shall affirm.
*554BACKGROUND
The record on appeal begins in the middle of a somewhat complex lawsuit. This appeal deals with but a small segment of that suit.1 Viewing the facts in Ponte's *501favor, in 2011 "a land failure" occurred at the intersection of Fricot City Road and Ross Thornton's driveway. Thornton hired a geotechnical engineer to evaluate the problem, and that evaluation revealed the problem was under the road, an area within the County's responsibility. Ponte alleges "it was agreed" with a county employee that the engineer would submit an estimate to the County, but since Ponte "was on site with his equipment," he would "expedite" the work. Ponte presented a bill for his services, which was rejected because, inter alia, he had not contracted in compliance with a plethora of County ordinances.
After much litigation-including cross-claims not relevant on appeal-the trial court granted the County summary judgment, and later awarded the County $65,000 in attorney fees, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 1038.2 After a judgment was entered, Ponte timely appealed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit