Court of Appeals of Texas December 21, 2017, NO. 01-17-00145-CV (Jackson v. Stroud)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-12-2017

Harvey Brown, Justice

This is an appeal from a take-nothing judgment entered after a jury trial in a medical malpractice case. Carolyn Jackson sued Daniel Garber Stroud, M.D., over the death of her husband, which occurred shortly after Stroud performed surgery on him. During voir dire, Stroud, who is Caucasian, used three of his peremptory strikes to remove all black panelists from the panel of potential jurors. Jackson, who is African-American, made a Batson challenge, which the trial court overruled.

Jackson argues that the trial court's ruling was an abuse of discretion because Stroud's race-neutral reasons for striking the black panelists were pretextual. We hold that the record shows that Stroud's reason for striking at least one of the *506panelists was pretextual. Therefore, we reverse the trial court's judgment and remand for a new trial.

Background

Heart surgeon Daniel Stroud performed bypass surgery on Jeffrey Jackson. Jeffrey died from complications related to the surgery, and his wife, Carolyn Jackson, sued Stroud for medical malpractice.1

During voir dire, one of four black panelists was struck for cause. At the conclusion of voir dire, Stroud used peremptory strikes to remove the three remaining black panelists. Jackson made a Batson challenge,2 which the trial court overruled. No black panelist was empaneled on the jury.

The jury returned a defense verdict, and the trial court signed a take-nothing judgment. Jackson appeals.

Batson Challenge

In her first issue, Jackson contends that the trial court abused its discretion in overruling her Batson challenge. After the trial court dismissed panelists for cause or hardship, Stroud used peremptory strikes to strike the three remaining black panelists-P. Howe, W. Parham, and K. Falls. Jackson made a Batson challenge, arguing that the strikes were racially motivated. Stroud proffered reasons for each strike, and the trial court overruled Jackson's objection.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.