Court of Appeals of Texas December 7, 2017, NO. 14-17-00184-CR (State v. Atkinson)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-12-2017

Kevin Jewell, Justice

This State's appeal involves the dismissal and refiling of charges against appellee Taylor Barrett Atkinson. After the State refiled the charges, the trial court dismissed the case on double jeopardy grounds, concluding that the State consented to a dismissal of the original case with prejudice. The State challenges the trial court's dismissal of the refiled charges, urging that: (1) the trial court lacked authority to dismiss the original charges with prejudice because the prosecutor did not seek such a dismissal; (2) jeopardy did not attach in the original case and, thus, dismissal of the refiled charges based on a claim of double jeopardy was error; and (3) a special plea such as appellee's must be taken with the case and decided by the trier of fact, instead of being determined during a pretrial hearing.

Because we conclude that jeopardy did not attach in the first instance, we reverse and remand.

Background

The State charged appellee by information with Class A misdemeanor driving while intoxicated ("DWI")1 in cause number 13-CCR-166390 (the "First Case"). When the First Case was called for trial, the State moved for a continuance.2 Appellee objected and announced ready for trial. The trial court denied the State's motion for continuance, and the State's prosecuting attorney moved to dismiss. The State filed a motion captioned "Motion to Dismiss," in which the State requested the court to dismiss the First Case "with leave to refile." On the same page as the motion's text appeared a proposed order stating that the cause was dismissed with leave to refile. Appellee objected to the *878motion to dismiss and again announced ready for trial.

An exchange then transpired that was not recorded and is not contained in our record but was later described under oath by appellee's counsel during the hearing on appellee's special plea, which is at issue in the present appeal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.