Court of Appeals of Texas August 23, 2017, No. 08-16-00038-CV (Apache Deepwater, LLC v. Double Eagle Dev., LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-08-2017

ANN CRAWFORD McCLURE, Chief Justice

In the world of oil and gas, it is no great secret that mineral owners generally prefer to have their minerals gathered and sold. The lease bonus paid at the outset of a mineral lease is nice, but a stream of royalty payments is better. On the other hand, mineral lessees must measure the cost to gather and bring the minerals to market against the expected return. They must prioritize where best to invest the substantial costs of hiring a drilling rig. At the intersection of these sometimes competing interests are three clauses in a typical oil and gas lease: (1) the habendum clause that sets a termination date for the lease unless the lessee is producing minerals from the leasehold; (2) the continuous development clause which similarly requires production or at least drilling activity; and (3) the retained acreage clause that defines what portion of the entire leasehold is protected from termination when the lessee develops some, but not all the land encompassed by the lease.1

Today we are asked to construe a lease containing variants of these clauses. The dispute arises out of a 640-acre leasehold that contains four equal proration units of 160 acres.2 At the end of the lease's primary term, at least one well was producing on each of those four proration units. All *652agree that the primary term of the lease was extended. With the passage of time, however, the wells on three of the 160 acre units stopped producing, and no new wells were developed on those units. In that context, does the one operating well on only one of 160 acre units extend the lease in favor of the lessee for the entire 640 acres, or only for the one proration unit that has an operating well? We conclude the entire leasehold is extended and we reverse the trial court's judgment to the contrary.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.